The Problem with Privacy and Surveillance
The Problem with Privacy and Surveillance
Privacy today has grown to have many different meanings with the growing number of surveillance tools and technological advances. We live in a world with numerous government agencies that can intrude upon the private lives and communication of innocent citizens. Does this collection of sensitive information generate invasion of privacy? The articles I found deal with the government spying on citizens in and out of the United States. The ability for the government to have access to everything in our lives has been abused, and if not reshaped will create the “Big Brother” none of us want to see.
The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) is a government agency responsible for securing the nation from threats we may face. Its mission’s involve anti-terrorism, border security, immigration and customs. A few weeks ago it was reported that the DHS is now tracking all internet activity of visa applicants, visa holders and green card holders. Along with visa applicants and visa holders, the DHS has implemented new rules for legal permanent residents and naturalized US citizens.They now track and store social media content as part of citizens files. This mass surveillance impacts the principles that our country was founded on. It poses the question of whether the rules inflict our free speech and free association rights. Immigrants may feel forced to have second hand thoughts before freely posting political views. The author of this article, Azadeh Shahshahani, is a naturalized citizen and believes that this surveillance is meant to keep immigrants political activity in-check, and to “keep them from feeling like full members of society”. Whether that is true or not, immigrants have been coming to the United States since its inception to leave tyrannical leadership and in hope of finding liberation. These covert acts of surveillance are very similar to what immigrants were facing in their home countries: systematic surveillance and self-censorship. Not only are immigrants facing the issue of government spying but members of the Black Lives Matter movement have also endured some of these hardships. The DHS and FBI have been surveilling the movement for Black Lives Matter and created an illegal program, COINTELPRO, that “kept surveillance on the movement in order to disrupt the ability to organize politically”. The surveillance that our government agencies take part in abridge freedoms that US citizens are guaranteed. America will quickly become a totalitarian state if there are not regulations made to what the government can view, store, and distribute.
This past November the Supreme Court saw one of the biggest Fourth Amendment cases in years. Timothy Carpenter was the leader of a series of armed robberies of cellphones in Detroit and was sentenced to 116 years in prison. The conviction was made because the cellphone service provider had 127 days of location data and turned it over to the police. Proving that his phone was in the vicinity of the robberies. Even though this is a major crime and jail time is deserved, police got the phone records without a warrant. The Fourth Amendment requires police to show they had probable cause. However when Mr. Carpenter appealed the conviction of violating the Fourth Amendment’s ban on unreasonable search and seizures, he lost in lower federal courts. He lost because of an old federal law with lower standards known as the “third-party doctrine” which gives the government access to phone location data held by third party service providers. Although this doctrine convicted Mr. Carpenter, he relied on it at the Supreme Court arguing that it is a poor match for the digital age and urged that it does not apply to modern communications data. He argued that “there needs to be revision to a decades old doctrine because of all our rapid, unforeseen technological advances".This case is very different from the privacy that immigrants are struggling with in our country. Even though there is a violation of privacy some may argue that it was for the greater good. Did the government abuse their right of surveillance even though they put a criminal behind bars? Even though both articles involve the same issue, one for the better and one for the worse, how should we determine what constitutes as too much surveillance? It is important for us to consider the rules that should govern the relationship between law enforcement and the public.
In the previous article’s we see how people in the United States are effected by “extreme” surveillance. In the New York Times article, “What It’s Like to Live in a Surveillance State” we get a representation of how a group of people outside this country deal with surveillance. There are a group of people in Northwestern China known as Uighur’s, indigenous Turkish people in the western region of Xinjiang. The Chinese Communist Party (CCP) considers this group of people to be dangerous separatists and control them in a manner much differently than how we operate in America. The city is covered with video cameras to recognize movements and has multiple checkpoints where the people get stopped. Uighur’s have to complete survey’s about ethnicity, religious practices and cultural level. The people get ranked as “safe” “normal” or “unsafe” and based on these categories the people will have rights to certain privileges. These are only a few things that a Uighur has to go through on any given day. The CCP justifies this security because the government cites the threat of foreign Islamist Ideology to Uighur’s. Authorities have even created regulations against Uighur customs: a law that bans face coverings, law that bans “abnormal beards” and recently several businessmen were jailed for not praying enough at a funeral. A Chinese official in Kashgar believes that these people must be subjected to these harsh policies because, “you can’t uproot all the weeds hidden among the crops in the field one by one — you need to spray chemicals to kill them all”. These conditions make the problem of privacy in the USA look like a teenager complaining about slow Wi-Fi. It is interesting to see how surveillance and privacy differ across the world and for different communities of people. It helps us realize that we, people living in US, do not have it all that bad. We fear the idea of the “Big Brother” taking over every aspect of our life while there are people currently fighting that reality and have been for years.
Invasion of privacy has so many different meanings because it is a complex issue that differs across cultures, ethnicities, geographic locations etc. Whether your text messages are being monitored or your vehicle has a government issued GPS tracking system, there is a growing problem with the degree of how far surveillance can go. In the United States of America there are many government agencies that want to protect us from interior and exterior threats. It is important for these agencies to not abuse the power they have in monitoring the life of citizens. However, it is also critical for US citizens to be cognizant of how people in other countries are effected by mass surveillance.
Comments
Post a Comment