Free Speech and the Internet

With the development of technology, internet is not something new. It improves the quality of people's life by providing platforms for business and communication. At the same time, freedom of the speech on the internet and its limitations have been an age-old debate topic.

The purpose of the U.S First Amendment is to protect U.S citizens' right to speak out. But does it mean that people can verbally attack others without legal regulation under the U.S First Amendment? In Nicholas Thompson's interview with the CEO of Instagram, Kevin Systrom, on free speech, artificial intelligence, and internet, Kevin points out that it is important to build a community where people feel free to express themselves; however, "look at the history of the law around free speech, there is a line where you don't want to cross because you're starting to be aggressive or be mean or racist." Inspired by LOLCats meme starter's "Prune the Trolls"strategy, Kevin and his co-founder Mike Krieger would delete comments and remove accounts that are considered "not so nice" to people. With the technology named "deep text"developed by Facebook, Instagram would be able to rate comments and detect bad comments based on the training set, with only 1 percent false positive rate. 

Even though companies have their own rules and ways to regulate "free speech" on the Internet on a limited scale, it is obvious that people don't buy any possibility of speech regulation on the internet, especially when it relates to politics. As mentioned in David Post's article "Protecting the First Amendment in the Internet Age", on ISIS problem, both Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton agree that Internet as ISIS terrorists' mean of communicating should be regulated. Nevertheless, Eric Posner, University of Chicago law professor, who stands on the same side with Trump and Hillary, notes that the law which regulates ISIS-related speech can be easily taken down by the courts under the First Amendment. Because it "would interfere with the right of people to receive or read political information-as would proposed laws that would require Internet companies such as Facebook and Twitter to remove ISIS-related propaganda from their websites." As David says, "countering propaganda is one thing-criminalizing the receipt and distribution of that propaganda is another.

On the other hand, a new problem has been raised by Kamatali, Jean-Marie in Wisconsin International Law Journal is that "new information technology is making speech made in the U.S by an American citizen accessible outside the U.S., exposing the speaker to consequences for violating the free speech limitations set in international law or the domestic laws of other countries."

In the article "Constitutional Myth #10: International Law is a Threat  to the Constitution" on The Atlantic Daily, Garrett Epps discusses whether the U.S Courts should consider or adapt foreign laws in Constitutional system. Given the statements of Sonia Sotomayor and Rep. Sandy Adams, in which they emphasize that "American law does not permit the use of foreign law or international law to interpret the Constitution.", Garrett states that "the fashionable revulsion against international law is of fairly recent vintage. It has nothing to do with 'original intent,' and it is deeply wrong and dangerous." As "James Wilson opposed giving Congress power to 'define' offenses against 'the law of nations,' on the ground that U.S. law could not change international law:'To pretend to define the law of nations which depended on the authority of all the civilized nations of the world, would have a look of arrogance, that would make us ridiculous."





Comments

  1. Regulating free speech has always been a contentious topic, but I think that this article does a great job of showing how this problem has been multiplied ten fold by the prevalence of the internet. I am not sure there is a perfect solution to trying to remove harmful content from the internet while also preserving people's constitutional right to free speech. I think that as the first article states it will have be an effort spearheaded by individual internet companies and not a sweeping national or international law.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Net Neutrality

Is privacy a fundamental right? According to some recent events, probably not.