Net Neutrality
One of the most hot-button political issues of the past year has been, without a doubt, the repeal of the FCC’s “net neutrality” rules. These rules were put in place during the Obama administration in order to keep huge internet providing companies from taking advantage of consumers and slowing down certain websites, especially those websites that conflicted with the company’s own business interests. For example, in 2012, before the rules were established, AT&T blocked Apple’s video chatting service FaceTime, because it conflicted with AT&T’s interests. AT&T eventually backed down under threat of an FCC complaint, but this and similar incidents caused the FCC to issue the Open Internet Report and Order in 2015, which is what people refer to when they say “net neutrality rules.” The repeal of these rules in December 2017 came amidst a storm of protest from the American public, but as the FCC is not directly beholden to voters, the repeal passed anyway.
The repeal is already setting off a whirlwind of legal responses, both from organizations taking the FCC to court and from elected officials relying on legal action to still force net neutrality upon their constituents. For example, according to a New York Times article from January 2018, Montana governor Steve Bullock, a Democrat, has signed an executive order declaring that internet service providers who have contracts with the Montana state government are not allowed to block websites or charge more for their faster delivery --two of the main provisions of the net neutrality rules.
In the same vein, According to a Washington Post article from February 2018, the FCC’s vote has now been published into the federal register, which now allows many opponents of the repeal to actually take the agency to court. The publishing of the vote also means that the necessary steps towards a congressional resolution, which would overturn the FCC’s vote, can now be taken. Unfortunately, the measure needs 51 Senate votes to be able to pass, and right now, with every Democrat and one Republican supporting the resolution, lawmakers are still one vote short. Furthermore, even if the resolution does pass the Senate, President Trump will most likely not sign it. The more feasible avenue for legal action against the FCC is a legal challenge, which is already in the works, as many groups have already filed lawsuits.
However, as an article from the Atlantic from November 2017 points out, the outrage against net neutrality is simplistic and misplaced, when one considers the actual state of the internet today. Even if Verizon and Comcast can’t slow down internet traffic from certain websites, there are still many barriers to a truly “open and neutral” web. In order to stay competitive, companies must manage their Google search results, restaurants and small businesses must have a presence on Yelp and OpenTable, and many start-ups begin with a goal of being acquired by a huge company like Google, Facebook, Amazon, or Netflix anyway. The author of this article simply asks that we step back and acknowledge the flaws in the internet many of us are trying so hard to protect.
The future of net neutrality remains uncertain, for now, but the way that things end up will certainly forecast the way the internet will be used in the years to come. However, whether the lawsuits or congressional resolution succeed or the FCC wins on behalf of huge internet providers, the internet will no doubt be a very different place, neutral or not.
The repeal is already setting off a whirlwind of legal responses, both from organizations taking the FCC to court and from elected officials relying on legal action to still force net neutrality upon their constituents. For example, according to a New York Times article from January 2018, Montana governor Steve Bullock, a Democrat, has signed an executive order declaring that internet service providers who have contracts with the Montana state government are not allowed to block websites or charge more for their faster delivery --two of the main provisions of the net neutrality rules.
In the same vein, According to a Washington Post article from February 2018, the FCC’s vote has now been published into the federal register, which now allows many opponents of the repeal to actually take the agency to court. The publishing of the vote also means that the necessary steps towards a congressional resolution, which would overturn the FCC’s vote, can now be taken. Unfortunately, the measure needs 51 Senate votes to be able to pass, and right now, with every Democrat and one Republican supporting the resolution, lawmakers are still one vote short. Furthermore, even if the resolution does pass the Senate, President Trump will most likely not sign it. The more feasible avenue for legal action against the FCC is a legal challenge, which is already in the works, as many groups have already filed lawsuits.
However, as an article from the Atlantic from November 2017 points out, the outrage against net neutrality is simplistic and misplaced, when one considers the actual state of the internet today. Even if Verizon and Comcast can’t slow down internet traffic from certain websites, there are still many barriers to a truly “open and neutral” web. In order to stay competitive, companies must manage their Google search results, restaurants and small businesses must have a presence on Yelp and OpenTable, and many start-ups begin with a goal of being acquired by a huge company like Google, Facebook, Amazon, or Netflix anyway. The author of this article simply asks that we step back and acknowledge the flaws in the internet many of us are trying so hard to protect.
The future of net neutrality remains uncertain, for now, but the way that things end up will certainly forecast the way the internet will be used in the years to come. However, whether the lawsuits or congressional resolution succeed or the FCC wins on behalf of huge internet providers, the internet will no doubt be a very different place, neutral or not.
I find the opinion piece very enlightening as it touches on how net neutrality should not only be ignored but how it shines light on how we view the internet. Reading this post, it seems as though there is much discussion on the policies in regulating the internet. And although the policies put in place are important as they dictate what occurs, the internet itself should also not be overlooked. it was great that you incorporated the opinionated Atlantic piece as well as informational articles as it gave a wider overview.
ReplyDeleteI found your commentary on the article from the Atlantic to be interesting. I think that its main point of acknowledging that there are flaws in a valid point, but I do not think that because flaws already exist in how truly free and equal the internet is people should then take more legislation designed at further restricting the internet lying down. Overall I think this article did a great job of showing how important of a discussion Net Neutrality is.
ReplyDelete