Social Media Information Warfare: Russian Meddling in the 2016 US Election
How Nations Attempt to Influence Others' Elections and Why the 2016 Russian Meddling in the US Election was Different
One of the main purposes of social media, such as Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter, is to allow people to voice and share their opinions with others freely. However, employees at the Internet Research Agency in St. Petersburg, Russia may have been using social media for a different purpose, influencing the United States 2016 election. According to RadioLab, the indictment by special counsel Robert Muller states that about 80 employees at the Internet Research Agency in Russia used social media to conduct “‘information warfare’ against the United States.” Their social media activities were similar to warfare, not in that it resulted in direct violence or death, but because their purpose was to “infiltrate the country with the idea of sowing chaos in the run-up to the 2016 election.”
While platforms, such as Facebook, have automated systems to prevent the sharing and spread of links to fake news stories, according to the Wall Street Journal, the Internet Research Agency took advantage of the social media companies’ insufficient protection against distorted and out of context pictures, videos and status updates that can be used for propaganda. Since these large tech companies rely heavily on users to report false information, the Internet Research Agency took special actions to try to make Americans not question the legitimacy of the pictures and posts. One way in which they were able to fool Americans into believing their distorted images were authentic was by adding a watermark to them. Also, these Russian agency employees would create a social media account using American names and cities in their social media accounts bios, and using somewhat fluent English, to further convince Americans that their posts were from a citizen of the US. By employing tactics, such as this, to their social media propaganda posts, the Internet Research Agency was able to make “the distorted pictures unusually effective weapons in misinformation campaigns.”
These tactics the agency used to meddle with the US 2016 election had been used and perfected when the Internet Research Agency attempted to influence Ukrainian politics in 2014. In his interview with RadioLab, Masha Gessen discussed how he would create blogs and social media posts distorting the news about the Ukrainian war to favor the pro-Russian rebels while he worked for the Internet Research Agency in 2014. Although he was able to make the posts in his native tongue, Gessen still had to pose as a Ukrainian citizen posting the distorted or entirely false information the agency required, in order to better influence and convince the real Ukrainian citizens.
However, St. Petersburg’s Internet Research Agency meddling in other countries' politics was not the first instance of countries engaging in information warfare, and attempting to influence other countries elections and politics. In fact, NPR’s FreshAir reported that “what the Russians did to our election was what the U.S. has done to other countries elections over the decades.” As early as the 1940s and 1960s, the CIA has attempted and has gone further than Russia did in 2016, to influence other nations’, including Guatemala, Iran, Brazil, politics, and elections by infiltrating their media and news channels. Some of the known tactics the CIA has employed in their information warfare against other nations include delivering suitcases full of money to the foreign nation’s political candidate that the US approved, and even paying to insert “true information, in some cases, that would hurt a particular candidate, in other cases, false information” into that nation’s newspaper.
What makes the Russian meddling in the US 2016 election different, and important from previous cases of countries meddling with others’ political affairs, is that much of the Russian meddling was done for little to no money by unaware Americans. In the past, a country would have to spend large amounts of money in order to influence other countries political outcomes, which was one of the tactics used by the CIA. While Russia did pay for polarizing ads on Facebook and other social media sites, according to NPR’s FreshAir, most of the Russian meddling was spread with little to no expense, organically over social by people “liking and sharing with their friends.”
The Russians at the Internet Research Agency ensured that they would reach large proportions of the American population by creating large quantities of material (in particular pictures and videos) that people were more likely to share. For example, Facebook “expects video will dominate its news feed within a few years,” what they call “Video First” as reported by the Wall Street Journal because they and other large social media companies have found that “people tend to share images and videos more than plain text.” In his interview with the Wall Street Journal, Dr. Wardle, who leads “a nonprofit dedicated to fighting digital misinformation that works with tech companies on some projects,” argues that images are very powerful in the current technological age of smartphones and social media because “we’re a lot less likely to stop and think, ‘does this look real?’” Therefore, by attempting to make videos and images that Americans would believe were legitimate, rather than articles or other text-based posts, the Russians were able to rely on the American public to quickly share their propaganda materials, reaching a large amount of the intended American population without having to pay for many ads.
Comments
Post a Comment