Freedom of Speech and the Internet
"The question of the extent to which public speech should be regulated despite the protections laid out in the First Amendment is not a modern debate. However, the ever growing role of the Internet and digital media as an outlet for expression of speech adds a new dimension to the discussion. There are, of course, numerous benefits to the freedom of speech without the bounds of regulation. However, in the age of the Internet, freedom of speech introduces scams, fake news, and trolls as the new menaces of society and allows such to reek havoc as they please. This calls into question where exactly the line should be drawn within the continuum between freedom and regulation, and what qualifies as necessary protection and what constitutes violation of rights."
In The Coming Speech Wars Online, Paul H. Jossey illustrates the power shift in speech regulation from the government to online companies such as Facebook, ultimately arguing that no organization should have control over what messages are displayed on the Internet and that it is ultimately the responsibility of the people to police speech. Control over Internet speech has shifted from the government to the hands of cyberspace corporations, especially in the realm of political communications. Jossey argues that political campaigns’ online presence matters more today than ever, visible in the power of a candidate’s mere tweet to sway the public opinion. The shift from high budget advertising campaigns to cyberspace crusades has made it increasingly difficult for the government to regulate political communications, and has thrust the responsibility into the hands of the companies whose online platforms are utilized, the “Silicon Valley Giants”. On these platforms ordinary people are able to exert huge political influence in their messages broadcasted to impressive followings. Thus, Jossey argues, information that is unfiltered by the government and untarnished by biases of companies is able to be distributed to the masses for the first time in history. This comes with a set of consequences, however, as fake news outlets misinform, Internet scams are commonplace, and trolls are allowed to harass anonymously. This has called for a movement to regulate the messages exhibited on the Internet in order to protect users from misinformation or harm. President Obama, noting that it was not the place of the government to restrict Internet speech, called for cyberspace companies to introduce a “curating function” to filter media according to “truthiness”. Jossey argues that this control of cyberspace media companies over the type of content published by users on their platforms will inevitably develop from cutting out what is untrue or harmful to introducing political or social biases over what is displayed and what is not. Jossey believes that trolls and scams will haunt the Internet whether speech is restricted by Internet companies or not, and that the public should worry less about these trolls than the power structures that attempt to govern them. In terms of who should hold the responsibility of policing speech on the web, Jossey argues that it is not the responsibility of the government or online companies, but the people who are active audiences of the media they consume.
In The Coming Speech Wars Online, Paul H. Jossey illustrates the power shift in speech regulation from the government to online companies such as Facebook, ultimately arguing that no organization should have control over what messages are displayed on the Internet and that it is ultimately the responsibility of the people to police speech. Control over Internet speech has shifted from the government to the hands of cyberspace corporations, especially in the realm of political communications. Jossey argues that political campaigns’ online presence matters more today than ever, visible in the power of a candidate’s mere tweet to sway the public opinion. The shift from high budget advertising campaigns to cyberspace crusades has made it increasingly difficult for the government to regulate political communications, and has thrust the responsibility into the hands of the companies whose online platforms are utilized, the “Silicon Valley Giants”. On these platforms ordinary people are able to exert huge political influence in their messages broadcasted to impressive followings. Thus, Jossey argues, information that is unfiltered by the government and untarnished by biases of companies is able to be distributed to the masses for the first time in history. This comes with a set of consequences, however, as fake news outlets misinform, Internet scams are commonplace, and trolls are allowed to harass anonymously. This has called for a movement to regulate the messages exhibited on the Internet in order to protect users from misinformation or harm. President Obama, noting that it was not the place of the government to restrict Internet speech, called for cyberspace companies to introduce a “curating function” to filter media according to “truthiness”. Jossey argues that this control of cyberspace media companies over the type of content published by users on their platforms will inevitably develop from cutting out what is untrue or harmful to introducing political or social biases over what is displayed and what is not. Jossey believes that trolls and scams will haunt the Internet whether speech is restricted by Internet companies or not, and that the public should worry less about these trolls than the power structures that attempt to govern them. In terms of who should hold the responsibility of policing speech on the web, Jossey argues that it is not the responsibility of the government or online companies, but the people who are active audiences of the media they consume.
"In How Twitter Killed the First Amendment, Tim Wu argues that in the age of the Internet, speech has become weaponized as used by the government as a means to control and suppress through the promotion of some ideas and the stifling of others. Wu notes the controlling efforts of the Trump white house in seeking to discredit the press, threatening to revoke the licenses of broadcasters, and calling for the dismissal of journalists simply due to the nature of their opinions. This sudden increase in coercive attempts of the government to control political debate represents a weaponization of speech used as a means to control. Wu describes the history of the utilization of speech as a political tool, which was first realized by the Russian government to spread pro-government news and counter criticism. China soon followed suit, effectively drowning out unfavorable speech by flooding the media with content meant to distract. Wu argues that our current state of chaos amongst the media ridden with trolls and scams is the result of this weaponization of speech with intent to suppress, confuse, and control. What is necessary according to Wu is a revitalization of the First Amendment in order to counter the increasingly intense attempts to censor and control Internet speech."
In Save Free Speech From Trolls, Lindy West shifts the debate concerning the freedom of speech on the Internet away from topics concerning government regulation, arguing that freedom of speech is being used as an excuse to continue to marginalize subjugated groups in how they are represented in media content such as television shows. West describes her experience of being labeled as an anti-speech censor in her criticisms of how women are portrayed in the media. The anti-speech charge has rapidly increased and is broadly applied to cultural criticism, and West argues that it is utilized largely by men on the Internet attempting to protect their right to harass marginalized populations for expressing their opinions. For example, feminist activist Anita Sarkeesian is taunted online by men who threat to rape, murder, and carry out mass shooting at her events where she advocates for better representation of women in the media. Her critics justify this behavior as declaring it as in defense to their freedom of speech and the ability to portray women in their media content as they choose. This however, is in an infringement upon Sarkeesian’s freedom of speech and her right to criticize what she does not agree with. West notes that millions of women’s lack true freedom of speech as they do not voice their opinions in fear of the responses they might receive by people like Sarkeesian’s critics. Similar to Wu’s argument surround the government’s use of speech as a tool, West argues that speech is being weaponized by particular populations in order to assume their cultural dominance in the ability to determine how groups are represented in the media. Their act of declaring criticism to the way they portray populations in unfavorable ways as a violation of the First Amendment creates a system where no poor work is put to rest, and chaos prevails.
The Internet has caused a shift how the First Amendment is interpreted and enforced. With it comes the potential for speech to be used as a weapon as a means to control and suppress, and should be regulated accordingly. However, the First Amendment protects the right of American citizens to freely express themselves in speech. The debate surrounding freedom of speech on the Internet searches for the ideal compromise between this regulation and freedom.
Comments
Post a Comment